I’ve slowly been reading the book What to Expect When You’re Adopting by Ian Palmer. I came across the book as I was checking out some titles that I have thought about using for a book, and this was one of the possibilities. When I saw that it already existed I was outraged, and then I bought the book to see what my competition would be like
(I’m kidding, I welcome every book written on the subject and appreciate the contribution that each of them makes.) I’m only about 1/2 way through this book, and unfortunately have not really “connected” with the information provided. For starters, it’s all based on adoption in England. The process is quite different if you’re in Canada, and then in Saskatchewan, so the particulars of the process in England are of little interest to me. I have also come across a few statements like this:
You have to be 100 percent certain that this is the right course of action for you, and those close to you. Dig deep, search your head and heart before committing to adoption; the consequences of getting it wrong are potentially devastating to all involved.
No pressure! And later:
There is no room for doubt.
SERIOUSLY? And then:
Accepting infertility involves a process of grief and mourning. Your adoption agency will want to know where you are in this process as it is important that you have grieved properly.
No offense intended, but this is almost laughable (when I get past the rage that it induces). The idea that you know where you are at in your grief seems impossible, and even more absurd is the idea of “grieving properly.” Give me a break! Also false (in my mind) is the implication that grief will end, and that it should end before you move forward. I strongly disagree with that. I don’t think grief of any kind ever ends, but rather it changes. It will always be there but in different forms, in different ways. Whether the grief is related to infertility or death or whatever other kind of loss, the idea that you grieve and then get on with it is not something that I can accept. Ah, if only it were true.
And the idea that there is no room for doubt immediately takes me out of the game. NO room for doubt? Do parents who are having a birth child not doubt what they are doing? How can you possibly not have doubts when the process of adoption is such an uphill battle? Seriously. Maybe I’m just overreacting here but these ideas are not ones that I can get on board with.
Ideally before, but certainly during, the assessment it will be important to know that you are settled in your own mind and have accepted you will be unable to have children. You will need to be comfortable with the changes this will have created in relation to your self-image – as well as issues relating to masculinity and femininity, potency and impotency – and be at peace with their social implications.
Again, I’m finding a lot of assumptions in this paragraph. The assumption that the people reading the book know that they will not have children. (If you’re dealing with unexplained fertility you cannot accept that you are unable to have children because you don’t know that.) And again, the idea that people will accept this and be “comfortable” with it seems far-fetched. And seriously, I have never before reading this paragraph even thought that I am less of a woman because of this, less feminine, but now I have something else to add to the pile.
That being said, I have also found truth in the book, and small nuggets of helpful information. For example, the author talks briefly about the reasons people adopt, the reasons people have kids at all. He discusses the cultural pressures to have children and that was interesting to me. There are good reminders that people can live fulfilling and valuable lives if they never have children. He talks about how intrusive the process of adoption is and the scrutiny involved, and how it so strongly goes against the value of privacy that we have in our culture. So, I will take the good with me and leave the stuff behind that is not so helpful.
I feel like I need to finish with a disclaimer. I understand that pregnancy and giving birth to a child are not at all easy. I don’t really see it as either one of them being worse than the other. It seems to come down to the fact that in general, getting kids is hard. And I’m sure raising them is even more difficult than getting them! (So why do people do this again?) The major problems for me occur when people say things like “You’re so lucky you’re adopting, you don’t have to gain all this pregnancy weight” or “Be glad you don’t have to spend money on diapers for the first year of your child’s life.” Things like that are problematic for me. I sincerely recognize and appreciate the difficulties in all of these things, but no, I am not glad, and I do not feel lucky.